Cinnamon Stick-Ups: Six King's Cross Mulled Wines and Mince Pies, Stress-Tested on Bare Fingers and Black Wool
Every November, King's Cross grows a second skin of gazebos, huts and chalkboard signs, and every November I hand over seven pounds to someone who has clearly been reheating the same pan since Bonfire Night. This year I decided to treat it like work. Coat: black wool. Gloves: confiscated at the door. Right hand: exposed to the elements and to justice. Six cups, six pies, four scoring columns and one running suspicion — that a fair chunk of what gets ladled out within sight of the station is hot orange squash that has merely been in the same room as a spice rack.
Here is the ledger. Nobody came out of it clean, least of all the coat.
How the scoring works
Four columns, each out of ten, plus a separate verdict on whether the booze is real.
Spice-to-sweet. Ten means you can genuinely taste clove, star anise and something faintly medicinal, with the sugar sitting underneath the fruit instead of on top of it. Zero means Ribena with ambitions.
Finger burn transfer. I held each cup by its naked body — no sleeves, no napkins, no cowardice — and timed the handoff to the other hand. Longer is better, unless it is long because the drink is lukewarm, which is a completely different offence.
Pastry-to-filling balance. The mince pie is a small structural miracle and it is routinely vandalised. Ten means dark, boozy, faintly sharp fruit inside a short pastry that does not taste of the cardboard it arrived in.
Crumb shed. Measured with a lint roller on the black wool, one sheet per stop. Fewer crumbs is better; a coat that looks like it has been sanded down is a fail.
Infusion verdict. Genuine, Probable, or Cinnamon Stick of Desperation.
Stop one: the canal-side chalet by the square
The first hut of the evening, half-lit and smelling aggressively of orange peel. The wine arrives with visible evidence — a strip of peel, a clove, something that might once have been a bay leaf — and the taste follows through. Clove up front, sugar in the middle, a decent dry finish that stops it tipping into pudding territory.
Spice 7. Finger burn 6 (twelve seconds before the handoff, a respectable burn). The pie is the highlight: proper short pastry, dark mincemeat with actual booze in it, a crimp that held together under pressure. Crumb shed 6, mostly along the right cuff.
Infusion: Genuine. Decor: aggressively Scandinavian. Score: 27/40.
Stop two: the pub courtyard off the Caledonian Road
This is the one you end up in because it is warm, has a door and does not require standing in a wind tunnel. The mulled wine is served so hot that it arrives with a visible plume and the immediate threat of a lip blister. Six seconds on the first hand, then a shameful switch, then a third switch to the cuff of the coat, which I have since apologised to.
That aside, the wine is the most convincing of the night — proper clove, black pepper, a hint of something citrusy underneath. The pie, however, was a tragedy: the pastry dry enough to be described as structural, the filling thin, the crimp like a Cornish pasty that had given up on life. It shed all over the coat with the enthusiasm of a thatched roof in a gale.
Spice 8. Finger burn 4. Pie 5. Crumb shed 3. Infusion: Probable. Score: 20/40.
Stop three: the market gazebo with the suspiciously cheap cup
Four pounds fifty. I should have known. The cup is warm rather than hot, which is its own small betrayal, and the first mouthful tastes of orange squash that has been shown a photograph of a cinnamon stick. No depth, no clove, no tannin, no nothing. It is a hot drink in the way that a bath is a swimming pool.
Cheap cups are drinkable luke-warm by design, so the finger burn score is a misleadingly excellent 9. The pie is a factory job, all sugar and no fruit, with a lid that lifted clean off like a manhole cover. Crumbs everywhere — a full lint sheet, front and both sleeves.
Spice 3. Finger burn 9 (by default). Pie 4. Crumb shed 8. Infusion: Cinnamon Stick of Desperation. Score: 24/40, and every one of those points is a lie.
Stop four: the hotel terrace with ideas above its station
Nine pounds fifty. In a glass. With a dehydrated orange wheel balanced on the rim like a small hat. You are paying for the glass, the blanket on the chair and the view of a hotel lobby, and I resented all of it right up until the first sip, which was excellent.
Star anise, clove, a proper red wine backbone, sweetness kept on a short lead. The stem of the glass turns out to be a genius piece of heat engineering — cool to hold, no handoffs, no blisters. The pie is served warm with a smear of brandy butter, which is either decadence or a bribe, and I accepted it either way. Slight crumb, neatly contained.
Spice 9. Finger burn 7. Pie 7. Crumb shed 5. Infusion: Genuine. Score: 28/40. Best wine of the night. Most expensive cup of anything I have drunk while standing up this year.
Stop five: the bakery counter, pie only
No wine here, so this is a pie-only entry, eaten on a bench in the cold like a character in a Victorian novel. And what a pie: all-butter pastry, mincemeat with real citrus peel and a slug of something dark, a lid that stayed put, a filling-to-pastry ratio you could teach a class on.
The crumb shed, however, was catastrophic. Buttery pastry does not so much crumble as explode. Two lint sheets. I now have a coat that looks lightly dandruffed in a festive way.
Pie 9. Crumb shed 2. Score, pies only: 11/20, with a moral victory.
Stop six: the late one by the station
Nine at night, most huts shuttered, this one still open and still pouring. The wine is decent rather than remarkable — clove present, sugar slightly forward, a finish that arrives and leaves quickly. The pie is fine. Everything here is fine, and at nine in the evening on a Tuesday, fine is a genuine public service.
Spice 6. Finger burn 8 (cup kept sensibly hot without violence). Pie 6. Crumb shed 6. Infusion: Probable. Score: 26/40 — with a bonus point for existing.
The final tally
| Stop | Spice | Burn | Pie | Crumb | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hotel terrace | 9 | 7 | 7 | 5 | 28 |
| Canal-side chalet | 7 | 6 | 8 | 6 | 27 |
| The late one by the station | 6 | 8 | 6 | 6 | 26 |
| Cheap gazebo | 3 | 9 | 4 | 8 | 24 |
| Pub courtyard | 8 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 20 |
Which cup is actually worth standing outside for
The hotel terrace wins on the booze, and if you can talk yourself into nine pounds fifty as a one-off treat rather than a habit, it is the only cup of the night I would willingly queue for again. The canal-side chalet wins on value and on pastry and is the one to take a visiting friend to. The pub courtyard has the best wine and the worst pie, which is a frustrating combination — drink there, eat elsewhere. And the cheap gazebo should be reported to somebody, though I am not sure to whom.
Four rules for the crawl
Hold the cup by the sleeve, not the rim. Your fingers will thank you and your dignity will survive the handoff.
Actually ask for the pie warmed. Half of the crumb shed on my coat came from pies eaten cold out of misplaced politeness.
Look for evidence. A whole clove, a strip of peel, a star anise floating about — that is a drink that has been somewhere. A lone cinnamon stick standing upright in the middle like a flag on a sandcastle is a warning.
Carry the lint roller in the pocket that is not full of napkins. This is the practical takeaway from the entire evening, and it cost me a black coat to learn it.